How to Choose Which Products to Bundle (A Data-Driven Strategy for Shopify Stores)
If you’re already experimenting with bundles, this is a great way to refine your product bundling strategy.
Tina Donati
Mar 07, 2023 · 11 min
How you can strategically approach your bundling strategy to improve your net income.
 
            Tina Donati
Mar 07, 2023 · 11 min
Tina Donati is the Head of Marketing at Simple Bundles and has spent the past 7+ years helping Shopify brands streamline their tech stack and unlock growth through smarter product bundling, better UX, and cleaner ops.
As your ecommerce business grows, so do your expenses—inventory management, shipping costs, and marketing spend can all eat into your profit margins. That’s why having a smart bundling strategy is key.
Product bundling—grouping two or more related or complementary products into one offer at a single price—is one of the most effective ways to increase sales, boost AOV (average order value), and streamline operations. Whether you’re a small business or an established retailer on Amazon or Shopify, bundling can help you turn individual products into profitable packages that feel like a win-win for you and your customers.
Bundling doesn’t just raise your conversion rate—it directly impacts profitability by improving efficiency, moving slow-moving inventory, and increasing perceived value.
The obvious win for you as a business owner is that product bundles are proven to improve net income. But these improvements aren’t just through conversions alone (since we all know a high conversion rate doesn’t necessarily mean your business is profitable).
Rather than looking at only one metric, product bundling offers several benefits for your business. These benefits will impact your profit margins—directly or indirectly. We break them into two categories:
“Generally speaking, as you add a second, third, or fourth item to orders, your shipping and pick-and-pack costs decrease as a percentage of your revenue. Voila—larger margins. So, the big benefit of bundles is that you can offer something to your customers that is more valuable to them and, at the same time, more gross profit for you.”
- Dave Rekuc, President of Bambu Earth
As much as we wish we could tell you product bundling is as easy as combining two products into one SKU and throwing it on your website, we both know there’s much more to creating a successful bundling strategy.
Let’s discuss how you can use bundling to your advantage and increase profit margins.
We reviewed successful strategies from our customers and spoke with ecommerce experts to uncover eight ways product bundles can improve your net income.
Consider the following tips when planning your next bundle campaign:
Analyze your cart and order data to see which individual products are frequently purchased together. That’s a strong indicator they’ll perform well as a bundle.
Use Shopify’s cart analysis report or customer segments to identify these trends. If you find a natural pairing (say, items bought together 5–10% of the time), offering a bundle at a discounted price can move that rate up to 30% or more—creating a direct lift in profitability.
Or, if there are specific products you want to track, you can set up segments using a filter that tracks when a customer purchases product A and product B in the last X days.
How often should these items be purchased together? Dave Rekuc, President of Bambu Earth, explains, “If you find a natural fit between two items—they're purchased together 5-10% of the time—that's a sign that a bundle with a discount could do very well. You can move that take rate to 30%+ if you offer a nice discount on that second product because you're reducing your pick and pack and shipping costs as a percentage.”
If you don’t have a lot of historical data to pull from, you can start by testing based on your intuition first and then iterating based on your sales performance.
Your “take rate” measures how often customers choose the bundle over buying items separately.
You can offer something that appears very high value but costs you a fraction of the perceived value. This can work wonders at moving the rate on the bundle. We did this and saw an increase from 30% take rate to 50%. This improved the gross margin on our first order considerably.
Here’s an example of this offer, which appears on users’ skin results page when they take Bambu Earth’s product quiz.
Note: Bambu Earth’s take rate of 30% may be considered high to them, but a “high take rate” for your brand may be a different number. If you have historical data to lean on to understand your take rate, start there. If you’re just starting out with product bundles, you may want to do some testing with cheaper freebies until you understand your profit margins better.
Using a tool like Simple Bundles can help you test bundle pricing strategies, analyze take rates, and see which bundles are most profitable.
Adding digital add-ons—like templates, how-to guides, or email reminders—can address customer objections while increasing perceived value.
For example, supplement brands often include a digital guide to staying consistent or meal-planning tips. These additions boost customer satisfaction and help justify higher bundle pricing.
Don’t expect bundles to sell themselves. Promote your bundling offers through your marketing strategy:
Source: Drink Surely
And, for your paid ads, make sure your bundle cost is higher than your cost-per-click.
“It’s very important to consider your profit margins when running paid ads. The reason is that a typical CPA on Facebook is $40 or more. If you run ads for a product or bundle that doesn’t have at least $40 worth of gross margin, you will lose money on your ad spend. If you create a bundle with a $60 gross margin, you can get a higher CPA and still be profitable,” said Matthew Larsen of Conversion Pages.
Bundle similar or same-product options together—like offering one, three, or six bottles of supplements.
This classic bundle pricing strategy nudges shoppers toward higher AOV choices while still feeling like they’re getting a better deal. It’s a simple, effective bundling method that works across categories.
These offers are standard, but you can take these one step further by showing each bundle across a landing page screen, placing the best value bundle in the middle of the three options.
If you do the middle bundle on the left, the highest value bundle in the middle, and the single product bundle on the right, many people choose the middle and highest value bundles, and your AOV goes up quite substantially.
You can come up with plenty of attractive offers your customers will enjoy. Who doesn’t love a freebie or a good sale? But since we’re speaking about profitability today, make sure your offers aren’t giving away too much.
“I create a bundle builder in a spreadsheet. My pick-and-pack costs mirror my structure, and I estimate the shipping cost for each item added. This helps me play with different combinations and find the ones at the intersection of what’s both profitable and attractive to customers,” explained Dave Rekuc of Bambu Earth.
Using this strategy. Dave created a simple bundle for Modern Fuel that asks customers if they want to add a pen to their pencil order. When buying these together, customers save $25. As a cherry on top, an additional upsell asks customers if they want to get a free engravement.
According to Dave, the take rate on this bundle is “exceptionally high.”
Another option to calculate your bundle profitability is to use a tool like Simple Bundles, which helps merchants streamline their fulfillment and picking-and-packing processes to save money and time.
“We’ve been using Simple Bundles for about six months, and it works perfectly. It allows us to break down products into individual components, which simplifies inventory tracking and order packing. Powerful yet simple.”
- SLAB Racks
You can try Simple Bundles for free by installing the app from Shopify.
When creating bundles for acquisition, gross profit per session (total cost of the sale minus the total cost to produce the good) should be your north star metric.
“That's how you create enough money to pay for your acquisition costs,” explains Dave Rekuc. “So, either a loss in gross margin is more than compensated by an increase in conversion rate. OR, you aim not to lose much conversion rate and increase total gross margin. Either path can result in more gross profit dollars per session.”
Let’s crunch some numbers to explain…
You operate a cosmetic brand that sells foundations and concealers. The foundations run at $45 (and cost you $15 to make), meaning your gross profit for your foundation is $30.
Your concealers are priced at $20 (costing $7 to make). The gross profit is $13.
Every week, you’re selling roughly 200 bottles of foundation and 50 tubes of concealer. That means your weekly gross profit for your foundation is $6,000. For your concealer, it’s $650.
After noticing your customers consistently purchase concealers and foundation, you create bundles for Black Friday. One bundle combines your foundation and concealer for oily skin. The other bundle is for the foundation and concealer for dry skin. Customers can purchase the bottles of the foundation and concealer for their skin type together for $65 (the total cost of buying each item separately but grouped by skin type for convenience).
For this scenario, let’s pretend your weekly purchase rate of 200 bottles of foundation stays the same (although in true Black Friday season fashion, this number would likely increase. But let’s keep things simple).
With shoppers buying the bundle instead of the items separately, you’re looking at these numbers…
That’s a 300% increase in gross profit for your concealers just by bundling products based on skin type.
With such a high increase in gross profit per session, you can safely add a $5-$10 discount on the bundle. This will make your bundle even more enticing, driving even more conversions.
**These scenarios don’t take taxes or other operational costs into account.
Gone are the days when product bundling had to be complicated.
Simple Bundles allows merchants to offer and compare bundle discounts against the bundle value. These discounts appear directly on their PDP to show customers the value they’re getting by purchasing a bundle rather than an individual product.
Detailed analytics also allows you to experiment with steepness in your discounts and respond quickly to fit what customers are looking for.
Visit us at Simple Bundles to learn more, or install Simple Bundles for FREE on the Shopify app store.
How do product bundles increase profit margins—not just conversion rate?
Bundles raise gross profit per session by nudging bigger carts (higher AOV), lowering pick-and-pack and shipping as a % of revenue, and consolidating marketing effort across multiple items. Net: more profit dollars per visit even if conversion rate stays flat.
What discount should I use on a bundle?
Work backward from unit costs + pick/pack + shipping + CPA. Pick a discount that increases AOV while keeping target gross margin. Quick rule: if adding a 2nd/3rd item barely increases fulfillment cost, you can pass a small discount and still widen margins.
Single-SKU vs. multi-SKU bundles: which protects margins better?
Simple Bundles supports both, and automatically breaks down bundles into components so stock deducts per item and fulfillment stays accurate.
How do bundles cut marketing costs?
Fewer campaigns to promote multiple items; higher AOV supports higher CPAs without going negative. If your bundle’s gross margin ≥ typical CPA, acquisition becomes more scalable.
What reports help me decide what to bundle?
Start with Shopify cart analysis and purchase combinations to find products bought together ≥5–10% of the time. Promote those pairs/sets as bundles and test a modest discount or bonus; then compare GPS and take rate before/after.
Can bundles help clear excess inventory without crushing margins?
Yes—pair overstocked SKUs with best-sellers or make them the free gift in a higher-margin bundle. You reduce deadstock carrying costs while protecting contribution margin.
How does Simple Bundles help with margin-focused bundle testing?